Samsung (Assurant) Trade in Practices

Have traded in a Galaxy Watch 5 44mm when purchasing the Galaxy Watch 8.
Their website does not give an option to choose whether the Watch5 is Bluetooth or LTE.
Assurant have assed the device and claim a mismatch. They claim I stated it is LTE, and it is not.
I did not claim it is LTE. No where does it give me an option to choose which variant it is.
So just a warning to those trading in watches.
I bought 2 watched and Traded in 2 Galaxy Watch 5, the other was a 40mm. Still awaiting for that to be assessed but interested to see what they do.
I blocked my payment card and also, there's a 0 balance on it anyway (Wise).

I CC'd Comcom in comms with Assurant and Samsung EStore email.
Comcom have stated they have logged the claim for assessment.
The value is $10 but it's the principle. I understand others have had bad experiences with Trade ins too.

Related Stores

Samsung
Samsung

Comments

Search through all the comments in this post.
  • Good luck with this! I do the same as you—I use a Wise digital card for the purchase, and then delete the card after I’ve received my order or when sending in my trade-in device. So far, I’ve had two successful trade-ins, but it’s important to cover yourself just in case something goes wrong.

    One thing I don’t like about the process is that, even though I select “no” for all the options about device condition—clearly indicating that my trade-in device isn’t working and is in poor shape—the paperwork always states the condition as “good.” That does make me a little nervous, but thankfully I haven’t had any issues myself.

    • I've had 2 good experiences before.
      1. Traded in a broken old iphone, claimed 'no' for all so wasn't worried about that. Yes, it also said 'good' in the initial paperwork as you mentioned.
      2. Traded in S22U and S22+ when S25 launched this year. Devices were immaculate but was worried about what they would do honestly. All went well though.

      While the wise trick will stop a payment, not sure if they could resort to other measures to retrieve payment.

      • Yea agreed, the Wise digital card trick is only good to stop them taking money, I'd assume they'd pursue things still though

  • Never had issues with the trade in (mine just completed yesterday)
    You might have a better response by emailing the CEO
    https://www.samsung.com/nz/support/contact/
    "Email the CEO option"
    We use that for issues the CS team don't seem to help with that should be fixed. (Warranty cga stuff etc)

    Sounds almost like they didn't consider LTE and WiFi models properly and you might have discovered a bug inadvertently but definitely in your case you should get the full amount considering they aren't very clear.

    • Never thought I would receive a response from that option. Assuming the CEO doesn't himself reply, have you at least got better support using that previously?

      When I received the trade-in mismatch email, I replied to Assurant direct, including the eStore email addy. Samsung just didn't reply and intervene even after multiple back and forth of me trying to explain to Assurant that the option wasn't even available.
      It was only after I stated the below:
      "This matter has been referred to the Commerce Commission and Disputes Tribunal. I do not authorise you to take payment from my credit card. This email serves as a legal document advising you that I do not authorise any charges on my credit card",
      that they forwarded my email to another generic Samsung trade-in email (I'm assuming it's the people at Samsung involved with the trade-in process), quoting my text as per above.
      They (Samsung trade-in email) then told me to accept the trade-in and they would process the refund so will wait and see.

  • Seems to luck of the draw. I traded in a s22 ultra with a broken charge port and they were fine. Also trade in a galaxy watch classic with a broken strap and no issues either.

  • Sent them a perfect S21 trade-in. Been in a case its whole life and with a glass screen protector.
    The initial value was $125; they gave me $5 because they claimed it was a model mismatch and the screen was not working. When I reached out to them, they sent me a picture of the phone with the screen working and looking fine, but then claimed the panel was damaged when the pictures THEY sent me proved otherwise. Asked them what they meant by model mismatch? and got no reply. Time was running out so I just accepted the trade-in because I didn't want to lose the $100 trade-in bonus. Was expecting a $225 saving, vs ended up with $105 saving.

    I didn't know about the WISE trick.

Login or Join to leave a comment